0022908: SameParameter & SameRange flags are set incorrectly in ShapeBuild_Edge::CopyRanges

ID	Project	Category	View Status	Date Submitted	Last Update

0022908	Open CASCADE	OCCT:Shape Healing	public	2012-01-16 20:10	2012-01-25 15:05

Reporter	~~ssv~~	Assigned To	~~ssv~~
Priority	normal	Severity	minor
Status	assigned	Resolution	open

Summary	0022908: SameParameter & SameRange flags are set incorrectly in ShapeBuild_Edge::CopyRanges
Description	The test is performed on the edge represented by Geom_Circle in 3D and B-spline curve in 2D. After invocation of ShapeBuild_Edge::Copy method, the resulting edge gets SameParameter & SameRange flags equal to 0 while ShapeAnalysis_Edge::CheckSameParameter returns OK on the initial edge (it is actually SP-edge with corresponding flags initially set as true). The cause of this issue is most likely in ShapeBuild_Edge::CopyRanges method which might incorrectly process the periodic curves. The test Draw command is attached along with the test file.
Steps To Reproduce	DRAWEXE pload ALL restore test_face.brep test_face SBE_test test_face
Tags	No tags attached.

Test case number	Test case is not required now

~~ssv~~ 2012-01-16 20:11 developer	test_face.brep (12,002 bytes)

~~ssv~~ 2012-01-16 20:12 developer	SSVSBETest.zip (1,885 bytes)

~~ssv~~ 2012-01-17 13:29 developer ~0019147 Last edited: 2012-01-24 09:50	Dear BugMaster, Please test branch http://svn/svn/occt/branches/SHG22908/. Need to know a list of regressions in order to proceed with this bug. Modified: code responsible for modification of parametric range of periodic curves commented out in ShapeBuild_Edge::CopyRanges.

apn 2012-01-18 10:58 administrator ~0019166	Dear BugMaster, Workbench KAS:dev:apn-22908-occt was created from SVN branch http://svn/svn/occt/branches/SHG22908/ [^] (and apn-22908-products from trunk) and compiled on Linux platform. There is regression in apn-22908-products regarding to KAS:dev:products-20111229-opt chl 918 D8 (checkshape res - Faulty shapes in variables faulty_1 to faulty_2) Unstable test cases: chl 927 S8 pkv 913 A1 See results in /QADisk/occttests/results/KAS/dev/ apn-22908-products_17012012/lin See reference results in /QADisk/occttests/results/KAS/dev/products-20111229-opt_29122011/lin See test cases in /QADisk/occttests/tests/ED

apn 2012-01-18 15:49 administrator ~0019171 Last edited: 2012-01-18 15:55	Branch http://svn/svn/occt/branches/SHG22908/ doesn't have source of SBE_test command. Add it, please. Also, change output by "cout" to "Draw_Interpretor", please.

~~ssv~~ 2012-01-21 12:32 developer ~0019219 Last edited: 2012-01-24 09:51	Dear Andrey (apn), Could you please re-test branch http://svn/svn/occt/branches/SHG22908/ now? The purpose is again to collect all regressions in order to proceed. Modified: code responsible for modification SameRange and SameParameter flags for edges with periodic curves commented out in ShapeBuild_Edge::CopyRanges. Concerning your remarks, I'd like to pount out the followings: 1. This issue is an auxillary one for 0022642 (I've just set the corresponding relationship above) and might not require any fix at all. 2. The provided test scenario (SBE_test) is not finalized yet, so we do not need to create any test case right now. Also, I didn't expect this SBE_test command to be integrated to OCCT, so what is the purpose of intergating it to branch? 3. About ustable test cases. Does it mean that "chl 927 S8" and "pkv 913 A1" became unstable after my modifications? Does this instability exist in products-20111229-opt_29122011?

apn 2012-01-24 08:41 administrator ~0019244	Dear BugMaster, Workbench KAS:dev:apn-22908-occt was updated from SVN branch http://svn/svn/occt/branches/SHG22908/ (and apn-22908-products from trunk) and compiled on Linux platform. There are following regression in apn-22908-products regarding to KAS:dev:products-20120120-opt checkshape is faulty: chl 908 A2 chl 913 J7 chl 917 C3 chl 918 D8 chp 003 D2 csh 006 A1 csh 007 A5 csh 007 B2 csh 007 B3 csh 007 B9 csh 007 C1 csh 007 C2 csh 007 D7 csh 007 D9 csh 007 E3 csh 007 E9 csh 007 F2 csh 011 A9 csh 011 C5 csh 011 E8 csh 011 G5 dec 007 B2 xigs 103 N7 xigs 203 W9 xsat 101 A9 xsat 102 U5 xsat 103 D7 xsat 104 N1 xsat 104 Y6 xsat 105 B3 xstp 106 L1 xstp 109 O2 xstp 111 U8 xstp 112 A2 xstp 112 A3 xstp 112 B1 xstp 112 G3 xstp 306 D6 xstp 311 W2 xstp 312 G5 can't read "shpp_a_o": no such variable: did 001 D5 did 002 A5 did 002 A7 did 002 A8 did 002 A9 did 002 C2 did 002 D4 did 002 D5 did 002 D7 did 002 D8 did 002 D9 did 002 E1 did 002 E2 did 002 E5 did 002 F7 did 002 F8 did 003 A2 did 003 B8 did 003 E2 did 003 E4 did 003 E6 did 003 E9 did 003 F8 did 003 F9 did 003 G1 did 003 H1 did 003 H3 did 003 I4 did 003 I6 did 003 I8 did 003 J1 did 003 J3 did 003 K9 did 003 M7 did 003 N4 did 003 N6 did 003 N9 did 003 O1 did 003 O3 did 003 P4 did 003 P7 did 003 S5 did 003 T5 did 003 T8 did 003 U4 did 003 U5 did 004 A3 did 004 A4 did 004 A5 did 006 B2 did 006 C9 did 006 E5 did 006 F5 did 006 F6 did 006 F8 did 006 G4 did 006 G7 did 006 H8 did 006 I1 did 006 J9 did 006 K7 did 006 L9 did 006 M2 did 006 M3 did 006 P3 did 006 Q9 did 009 D1 did 009 F9 did 012 A4 See results in /QADisk/occttests/results/KAS/dev/ apn-22908-products_23012012/lin See reference results in /QADisk/occttests/results/KAS/dev/products-20120120-opt_20012012/lin See test cases in /QADisk/occttests/tests/ED

~~ssv~~ 2012-01-24 09:36 developer ~0019246 Last edited: 2012-01-24 09:54	Dear Andrey (apn), Could you please re-test http://svn/svn/occt/branches/SHG22908/ ? Modified: optional flag to allow/avoid modifications on ranges introduced in ShapeBuild_Edge::CopyRanged (copyAsIs parameter). This flag is set as TRUE in ShapeBuild_ReShape::Apply method.

apn 2012-01-25 15:03 administrator ~0019262 Last edited: 2012-01-25 15:04	Dear BugMaster, Workbench KAS:dev:apn-22908-occt was updated from SVN branch http://svn/svn/occt/branches/SHG22908/ (and apn-22908-products from trunk) and compiled on Linux platform. There are regressions in apn-22908-products regarding to KAS:dev:products-20111229-opt chl 902 F9 F9 chl 902 G2 G2 chl 903 A5 A5 chl 908 A2 A2 chl 908 A8 A8 chl 913 J7 J7 chl 917 C3 C3 chl 918 D7 D7 chl 918 D8 D8 chl 918 K6 K6 chl 919 A1 A1 chl 919 D1 D1 chl 919 G8 G8 chl 919 W7 W7 chl 921 A3 A3 chl 921 B3 B3 chl 927 E9 E9 chl 927 M8 M8 chl 927 P1 P1 chl 928 Q6 Q6 chl 928 Y3 Y3 chl 928 Y4 Y4 chl 934 B1 B1 chl 934 G8 G8 chl 934 I3 I3 chl 937 B4 B4 chl 937 B5 B5 chl 940 A1 A1 chl 918 D1 D1 chl 927 M9 M9 chl 927 Y4 Y4 chl 934 G7 G7 chl 937 A5 A5 chl 937 A6 A6 chl 937 A7 A7 chl 937 A8 A8 chl 937 B6 B6 chl 937 B7 B7 chp 003 A4 A4 chp 003 A9 A9 chp 003 B4 B4 chp 003 B8 B8 chp 003 B9 B9 chp 003 C3 C3 chp 003 C4 C4 chp 003 C6 C6 chp 003 D2 D2 chp 003 D5 D5 chp 003 D6 D6 chp 003 E5 E5 chp 003 E7 E7 chp 004 A6 A6 chp 004 A7 A7 chp 004 B2 B2 chp 005 A2 A2 cra 001 B3 B3 csh 002 A1 A1 csh 002 A2 A2 csh 002 A3 A3 csh 002 A4 A4 csh 002 A5 A5 csh 002 A6 A6 csh 002 A7 A7 csh 002 A8 A8 csh 002 A9 A9 csh 002 B1 B1 csh 002 B2 B2 csh 002 B3 B3 csh 006 A1 A1 csh 006 A2 A2 csh 006 A3 A3 csh 006 A5 A5 csh 007 A1 A1 csh 007 A5 A5 csh 007 A6 A6 csh 007 A7 A7 csh 007 A9 A9 csh 007 B2 B2 csh 007 B3 B3 csh 007 B4 B4 csh 007 B5 B5 csh 007 B9 B9 csh 007 C1 C1 csh 007 C2 C2 csh 007 D1 D1 csh 007 D2 D2 csh 007 D3 D3 csh 007 D4 D4 csh 007 D7 D7 csh 007 D9 D9 csh 007 E1 E1 csh 007 E2 E2 csh 007 E3 E3 csh 007 E4 E4 csh 007 E5 E5 csh 007 E9 E9 csh 007 F2 F2 csh 009 A1 A1 csh 009 A2 A2 csh 009 A3 A3 csh 009 A4 A4 csh 009 A5 A5 csh 009 A6 A6 csh 009 A7 A7 csh 009 A8 A8 csh 009 A9 A9 csh 009 B2 B2 csh 009 B3 B3 csh 009 B4 B4 csh 009 B5 B5 csh 009 B6 B6 csh 009 B7 B7 csh 009 B8 B8 csh 009 C2 C2 csh 009 C4 C4 csh 009 C7 C7 csh 009 C8 C8 csh 009 D2 D2 csh 009 D3 D3 csh 009 D4 D4 csh 009 D5 D5 csh 009 D6 D6 csh 009 D9 D9 csh 009 E4 E4 csh 009 E5 E5 csh 009 E6 E6 csh 009 E7 E7 csh 009 E8 E8 csh 009 E9 E9 csh 009 F1 F1 csh 009 F2 F2 csh 009 F3 F3 csh 009 F4 F4 csh 009 F5 F5 csh 010 A1 A1 csh 010 A2 A2 csh 010 A3 A3 csh 010 A4 A4 csh 010 A5 A5 csh 010 A8 A8 csh 010 B1 B1 csh 010 B6 B6 csh 010 B7 B7 csh 010 C1 C1 csh 010 C2 C2 csh 010 C3 C3 csh 010 C4 C4 csh 010 C5 C5 csh 010 C6 C6 csh 010 C7 C7 csh 010 C8 C8 csh 010 C9 C9 csh 010 D1 D1 csh 010 D2 D2 csh 011 A1 A1 csh 011 A2 A2 csh 011 A5 A5 csh 011 A9 A9 csh 011 B2 B2 csh 011 B4 B4 csh 011 B6 B6 csh 011 B7 B7 csh 011 B8 B8 csh 011 B9 B9 csh 011 C4 C4 csh 011 C5 C5 csh 011 C6 C6 csh 011 C9 C9 csh 011 D2 D2 csh 011 D5 D5 csh 011 D6 D6 csh 011 D7 D7 csh 011 D8 D8 csh 011 D9 D9 csh 011 E6 E6 csh 011 E7 E7 csh 011 F3 F3 csh 011 F6 F6 csh 011 G5 G5 dea 001 A2 A2 dea 001 A4 A4 dea 001 A5 A5 dea 001 B3 B3 dec 004 A1 A1 dec 004 E2 E2 dec 006 A4 A4 dec 006 D9 D9 dec 006 E1 E1 dec 006 E3 E3 dec 006 E7 E7 dec 006 I1 I1 dec 007 I3 I3 dec 007 I7 I7 dec 007 J7 J7 dec 007 L1 L1 can't read "shpp_a_o": no such variable: did (all) msh 004 A2 A2 xdxf 101 L4 L4 xigs 001 A2 A2 xigs 102 L9 L9 xigs 103 S8 S8 xigs 104 A9 A9 xigs 104 B4 B4 CHECKSHAPE : Faulty NBSHAPES : Faulty xsat xstp xx_t 101 A8 A8 xx_t 101 B1 B1 xx_t 101 C1 C1 xx_t 101 C8 C8 xx_t 101 D2 D2 xx_t 101 D7 D7 xx_t 101 E2 E2 xx_t 101 E9 E9 See results in /QADisk/occttests/results/KAS/dev/ apn-22908-products_24012012/lin See reference results in /QADisk/occttests/results/KAS/dev/products-20120120-opt_20012012/lin See test cases in /QADisk/occttests/tests/ED

Date Modified	Username	Field	Change
2012-01-16 20:10	~~ssv~~	New Issue
2012-01-16 20:10	~~ssv~~	Assigned To	=> ssv
2012-01-16 20:11	~~ssv~~	Status	new => assigned
2012-01-16 20:11	~~ssv~~	File Added: test_face.brep
2012-01-16 20:12	~~ssv~~	File Added: SSVSBETest.zip
2012-01-16 20:13	~~ssv~~	Steps to Reproduce Updated
2012-01-16 20:15	~~ssv~~	Description Updated
2012-01-17 13:29	~~ssv~~	Note Added: 0019147
2012-01-17 13:29	~~ssv~~	Status	assigned => resolved
2012-01-17 13:30	~~ssv~~	Status	resolved => reviewed
2012-01-18 10:58	apn	Note Added: 0019166
2012-01-18 10:58	apn	Status	reviewed => assigned
2012-01-18 15:49	apn	Note Added: 0019171
2012-01-18 15:55	apn	Note Edited: 0019171
2012-01-21 11:56	~~ssv~~	Relationship added	child of 0022642
2012-01-21 12:32	~~ssv~~	Note Added: 0019219
2012-01-23 09:51	~~ssv~~	Status	assigned => resolved
2012-01-23 09:51	~~ssv~~	Status	resolved => reviewed
2012-01-24 08:41	apn	Note Added: 0019244
2012-01-24 08:42	apn	Test case number	=> Test case is not required now
2012-01-24 08:42	apn	Status	reviewed => assigned
2012-01-24 09:36	~~ssv~~	Note Added: 0019246
2012-01-24 09:36	~~ssv~~	Status	assigned => resolved
2012-01-24 09:37	~~ssv~~	Status	resolved => reviewed
2012-01-24 09:50	~~ssv~~	Note Edited: 0019147
2012-01-24 09:51	~~ssv~~	Note Edited: 0019219
2012-01-24 09:53	~~ssv~~	Note Edited: 0019246
2012-01-24 09:54	~~ssv~~	Note Edited: 0019246
2012-01-24 09:54	~~ssv~~	Note Edited: 0019246
2012-01-25 15:03	apn	Note Added: 0019262
2012-01-25 15:04	apn	Note Edited: 0019262
2012-01-25 15:05	apn	Status	reviewed => assigned

View Issue Details

Attached Files

Relationships

Activities

Issue History